Choosing between ice cube trays comes down to how much ice you need, how easily you want cubes to release, and whether lids or a storage bin will help in your freezer. My best overall pick is the OXO Good Grips Flexible Ice Cube Tray with Lid, which pairs a flexible design with a lid in a straightforward two-tray set. For larger batches, the Weftnom 5-Pack lists 70 cubes, while the DOQAUS set with a storage bin and scoop brings more storage pieces together. The main tradeoffs are compactness versus capacity, silicone flexibility versus a firmer tray, and a simple set versus one with extra accessories. Read on for the full breakdown and a guide to choosing a tray setup that suits your kitchen.
Get the little things that make your day delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Key Takeaways
- OXO is my overall pick for pairing a flexible tray design with a lid in a simple two-tray set, rather than adding a storage bin or scoop.
- The Weftnom 5-Pack is the batch-size standout: its listed 70-cube capacity gives it a different role from the smaller two-tray options.
- The DOQAUS set with a bin and scoop favors an all-in-one setup, while a basic tray set makes more sense if you do not need those extras.
- Silicone appears across many of the listings, but flexible material alone does not settle the choice: tray count, lids, and how the set stores matter too.
- Two DOQAUS listings describe the same 4-piece set with lids, a storage bin, and a scoop, so the roundup treats them as a duplicate listing rather than meaningfully different designs.
| OXO Good Grips Flexible Ice Cube Tray with Lid, 2 Pack |  | Best Overall | Pack size: 2 trays | Color: Blue and white | Lid: Sliding and stackable | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Weftnom Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lids, 3-Pack |  | Best for Multi-Use Freezing | Quantity: 3 trays | Materials: Polypropylene and silicone | BPA free: Yes | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| BPA-Free Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Removable Lids, 2-Pack |  | Best for Flexible Batch Prep | Number of trays: 2 | Total capacity: 28 ice cubes | Materials: Silicone, TPE, and PP | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Stackable Ice Cube Trays with Lids and Storage Bin, 4-Pack |  | Best for High-Volume Storage | Tray count: 4 | Cubes per tray: 12 | Total capacity: 48 cubes | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Arrow Plastics Eezy Out Ice Cube Trays, 2-Pack |  | Best Basic Interlocking Trays | Pack size: 2 trays | Cubes per tray: 14 | Total capacity: 28 cubes | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| DOQAUS Ice Cube Tray Set with Lids, Storage Bin, and Scoop, 4-Pack |  | Best Ice-Making and Serving Kit | Tray count: 4 | Material: Silicone | Included accessories: Storage container and scoop | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Kitch Ice Tray Easy-Release White Ice Cube Trays, 16 Cubes per Tray, Pack of 2 |  | Best Simple, No-Fuss Pick | Quantity: 2 trays | Capacity per tray: 16 cubes | Total capacity: 32 cubes | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Weftnom Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lids, 5-Pack, 70 Cubes |  | Best for High-Capacity Batches | Quantity: 5 trays | Cubes per tray: 14 | Total capacity: 70 cubes | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| ChefAide 4-Pack Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lids |  | Best for Covered, Stackable Trays | Number of trays: 4 | Cubes per tray: 14 | Total capacity: 56 cubes | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| DOQAUS Ice Cube Tray Set with Lids, Storage Bin, and Scoop, 4 Pack |  | Best BPA-Free Storage Set | Included: 4 silicone ice cube trays, storage bin, and scoop | Materials: Food-grade silicone and durable plastic | BPA-free: Yes | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| 5-Pack Stackable Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lids, Black |  | Best High-Volume Set | Quantity: 5 trays | Capacity per tray: 14 cubes | Total capacity: 70 cubes | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| DOQAUS Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lids, 4-Pack |  | Best for Easy-Care Silicone | Quantity: 4 trays | Dimensions: 10 × 4.1 × 3 in | Materials: Silicone and polypropylene | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Rubbermaid Easy Release Ice Cube Trays, 2-Pack, Light Purple |  | Best for Low-Fuss Durability | Pack size: 2 trays | Color: Light purple | Release design: Designed for easy release | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Kitch Easy Release White Ice Cube Trays, 4-Pack |  | Best Made-in-USA Pick | Pack size: 4 trays | Cubes per tray: 16 | Total capacity: 64 cubes | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| 8-Pack Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Removable Lids, 14 Cubes per Tray |  | Best for Defined Cube Dimensions | Pack size: 8 trays | Cubes per tray: 14 | Stated total capacity: 56 cubes; inconsistent with 8 trays × 14 cubes | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| ice cube tray | Materials | Total capacity |
|---|---|---|
| OXO Good Grips Flexible Ice Cu | — | — |
| Weftnom Silicone Ice Cube Tray | Polypropylene and silicone | — |
| BPA-Free Silicone Ice Cube Tra | Silicone, TPE, and PP | 28 ice cubes |
| Stackable Ice Cube Trays with | Plastic and silicone | 48 cubes |
| Arrow Plastics Eezy Out Ice Cu | — | 28 cubes |
| DOQAUS Ice Cube Tray Set with | — | — |
| Kitch Ice Tray Easy-Release Wh | — | 32 cubes |
| Weftnom Silicone Ice Cube Tray | Food-grade silicone and PP frame | 70 cubes |
| ChefAide 4-Pack Silicone Ice C | Silicone and food-grade PP | 56 cubes |
| DOQAUS Ice Cube Tray Set with | Food-grade silicone and durable plastic | — |
| 5-Pack Stackable Silicone Ice | Food-grade silicone and PP | 70 cubes |
| DOQAUS Silicone Ice Cube Trays | Silicone and polypropylene | — |
| Rubbermaid Easy Release Ice Cu | — | — |
| Kitch Easy Release White Ice C | — | 64 cubes |
| 8-Pack Silicone Ice Cube Trays | Silicone, TPE, and PP | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
OXO Good Grips Flexible Ice Cube Tray with Lid, 2 Pack
I’d put the OXO Good Grips Flexible Ice Cube Tray near the top for everyday freezing because its sliding lid lets you take a few cubes without lifting off a full cover. The lid also stacks and helps shield ice from freezer odors, a useful combination that the simpler Arrow Plastics Eezy Out trays don’t offer. Its rounded cubes and flexible tray are geared toward easier release, while dishwasher-safe, BPA-free construction keeps care straightforward. The tradeoff is that this two-tray set offers less built-in capacity than the four-tray Stackable Ice Cube Trays with Lids and Storage Bin. The sliding mechanism also adds a part to manage, so I’d favor this set for controlled access and tidy storage, not maximum batch output.
Pros:- Sliding lid lets you access cubes without removing the entire cover
- Stackable lid helps organize freezer space
- Cover helps protect ice from freezer odors
- Dishwasher-safe and BPA-free construction
Cons:- Two trays offer less batch capacity than the four-tray storage-bin set
- Sliding lids add a mechanism compared with basic interlocking trays
Best for: Households that use ice regularly and want covered, stackable trays with convenient access to a few cubes at a time
Not ideal for: People who need to freeze a large batch at once or prefer the simplest possible tray without a sliding lid
- Pack size:2 trays
- Color:Blue and white
- Lid:Sliding and stackable
- Ice cube shape:Rounded
- Care:Dishwasher safe
- BPA free:Yes
Our verdict“Choose this set for convenient, covered everyday ice access rather than the largest freezer batch.”
Weftnom Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lids, 3-Pack
I’d choose the Weftnom three-pack for a freezer routine that goes beyond plain water: the trays are listed for ice, frozen fruit, coffee, and other treats. Flexible silicone bases help release contents, while polypropylene edges give each tray a more structured frame than a fully flexible mold. Its stackable lids help contain spills and odors, features the basic Arrow Plastics Eezy Out trays lack. Compared with the OXO Good Grips Flexible Ice Cube Tray, this set supplies a third tray and square cubes, but it doesn’t offer OXO’s sliding access. The main limitation is that capacity per tray isn’t specified, so I can’t recommend it to buyers who need a known cube count. Pick it for varied freezing jobs, not precise batch planning.
Pros:- Three trays provide more separate molds than a two-pack
- Flexible silicone bases aid cube release
- Lids help limit spills and freezer odors
- Stackable, dishwasher-safe, BPA-free design
Cons:- Capacity per tray is not specified
- Does not have the OXO set’s sliding access feature
Best for: Cooks and drink makers who want several lidded trays for freezing ice, coffee, fruit, or other small portions
Not ideal for: Buyers who need a stated cube count or want to remove individual cubes through a sliding lid
- Quantity:3 trays
- Materials:Polypropylene and silicone
- BPA free:Yes
- Color:Sage green
- Shape:Square
- Item weight:0.31 kg
- Dimensions:9.9 × 4.2 × 3.2 in
- Care:Dishwasher safe
- Model number:ICT-3P-14-MG
Our verdict“Pick Weftnom if you want three covered trays for varied freezer uses and can work without a stated capacity.”
BPA-Free Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Removable Lids, 2-Pack
This two-pack earns its place for buyers who want to freeze more than drinks: its 28-cube total capacity and flexible bottoms suit juice, sauces, purees, and other small portions. Removable lids help block dust and freezer odors and let the trays stack, while dishwasher-safe construction simplifies cleanup. Compared with the OXO Good Grips Flexible Ice Cube Tray, this set gives a stated cube count and removable rather than sliding lids; OXO’s design is better for reaching cubes without taking off the whole cover. The tradeoff here is that the lids must come off for access, and the instructions call for boiling the trays before first use. I’d choose it for portioning assorted ingredients, but less readily for buyers who want minimal setup or a sliding lid.
Pros:- Two trays make 28 cubes total
- Flexible bottoms make cubes easier to release
- Removable lids help block odors and dust and allow stacking
- Dishwasher-safe and suitable for freezing more than water
Cons:- Instructions recommend boiling trays before first use
- Removable lids must be taken off to access cubes
Best for: Meal preppers and home cooks who want a known 28-cube capacity for freezing sauces, purees, juice, and ice
Not ideal for: People who want to access cubes through a sliding cover or avoid a special first-use preparation step
- Number of trays:2
- Total capacity:28 ice cubes
- Materials:Silicone, TPE, and PP
- BPA free:Yes
- Lid:Removable
- Care:Dishwasher safe
Our verdict“Choose this set for flexible, measured batch prep across drinks and cooking portions, provided the first-use step suits you.”
Stackable Ice Cube Trays with Lids and Storage Bin, 4-Pack
For buyers who want a larger supply ready in the freezer, this set combines four trays and a storage bin for 48 cubes total. Each tray makes 12, so the set’s advantage comes from having multiple trays and a place to keep extra cubes—not from a high yield per mold. Soft silicone bottoms support easier release, and fitted lids help protect ice from freezer odors while allowing the trays to stack. That makes it a more storage-focused choice than the two-tray OXO Good Grips Flexible Ice Cube Tray, though OXO’s sliding lid is more convenient when taking just a few cubes. The four-tray arrangement needs room, and 12 cubes per tray may feel slow if you refill one tray at a time. I’d pick it for households that can use the full stack.
Pros:- Four trays make 48 cubes in total
- Included bin stores extra cubes
- Soft silicone bottoms aid release
- Lids and stackable design help protect and organize ice
Cons:- Each tray makes only 12 cubes
- Four trays and a storage bin take more freezer space than a two-pack
Best for: Households that use plenty of ice and have freezer room for several covered trays plus a storage bin
Not ideal for: Small households with limited freezer space or buyers who want a high cube yield from each individual tray
- Tray count:4
- Cubes per tray:12
- Total capacity:48 cubes
- Cube dimensions:1.7 × 1.1 × 0.8 inches
- Materials:Plastic and silicone
- Included components:1 storage bin and 4 ice trays
- Features:Lids, stackable design, and soft silicone bottoms
- Care:Dishwasher safe
- BPA free:Yes
Our verdict“Choose this set when total supply and a dedicated cube bin matter more than yield from each individual tray.”
Arrow Plastics Eezy Out Ice Cube Trays, 2-Pack
I’d point buyers who want a straightforward tray toward the Arrow Plastics Eezy Out two-pack: each tray makes 14 cubes, and the interlocking design keeps the pair stackable without a separate lid system. Its plastic construction and simple format contrast with the Weftnom Silicone Ice Cube Trays, which add flexible bases, lids, and broader freezing uses. That simplicity is also the main compromise. The Arrow trays don’t list odor protection or a flexible release base, so they’re less suited to freezer storage where uncovered ice may pick up surrounding smells. Their 28-cube combined capacity is clearly stated, but the set lacks the extra bin offered by the four-pack Stackable Ice Cube Trays. I’d choose Arrow for basic, stackable ice making and skip it if covered storage or easier release is a priority.
Pros:- Two trays make 28 cubes combined
- Interlocking design supports stacking
- Each tray’s 14-cube capacity is stated
- Made in the USA
Cons:- Plastic construction lacks a flexible release base
- No lids are listed to help protect ice from freezer odors
Best for: Buyers who want two simple, stackable trays with a stated 14-cube capacity per tray
Not ideal for: People who need covered, odor-protective storage or prefer flexible bottoms for releasing cubes
- Pack size:2 trays
- Cubes per tray:14
- Total capacity:28 cubes
- Material:Plastic
- Stacking:Interlocking trays
- Made in:USA
Our verdict“Choose Arrow for basic interlocking trays with a clear cube count, not for covered storage or flexible release.”
DOQAUS Ice Cube Tray Set with Lids, Storage Bin, and Scoop, 4-Pack
This set is designed for people who want to make, store, and serve ice with one group of accessories. Its four flexible silicone trays offer more batch capacity than the two-tray Kitch Ice Tray set, while the included storage bin and scoop make it easier to keep finished cubes together. Textured lids with handles and a stackable layout also help organize a crowded freezer. The main compromise is lid coverage: these lids allow airflow, so they may not block freezer odors as well as the removable lids on the ChefAide 4-Pack. I’d choose the DOQAUS when serving and storage matter as much as cube release, but skip it if you need a tightly sealed tray or want the fewest pieces to wash.
Pros:- Four trays provide capacity for multiple batches
- Storage bin and scoop support organized storage and serving
- Flexible silicone is designed to release cubes with gentle pressure
- Stackable components help use freezer space efficiently
Cons:- Lids allow airflow and may not fully block freezer odors
- Four trays plus the bin and scoop require room for several components
Best for: Households that make several trays of ice and want a bin and scoop for serving and freezer organization
Not ideal for: Buyers who need airtight lids to keep ice isolated from strong freezer odors
- Tray count:4
- Material:Silicone
- Included accessories:Storage container and scoop
- Lids:Textured lids with handles
- Freezer storage:Stackable design
- Cleaning:Top-rack dishwasher safe
Our verdict“Choose this set if you want an all-in-one ice-making and serving setup and can work with non-airtight lids.”
Kitch Ice Tray Easy-Release White Ice Cube Trays, 16 Cubes per Tray, Pack of 2
The Kitch set suits buyers who want straightforward trays rather than a larger kit with storage pieces. Two 16-cube trays make 32 cubes per batch, and their flexible construction lets you twist the trays to release ice without pressing individual cubes out. Compared with the ChefAide 4-Pack, Kitch supplies fewer trays and does not list removable lids, so it takes less gear to manage but offers less protection and batch capacity. The stackable shape helps keep the pair orderly in the freezer, and dishwasher-safe, BPA-free construction simplifies routine cleanup. I’d favor this set for basic daily use; buyers who need covered trays, a storage bin, or a larger supply should choose a more complete set instead.
Pros:- Two trays make 32 cubes per batch
- Flexible trays release cubes with a twist
- BPA-free construction
- Dishwasher-safe and stackable
Cons:- No lids or storage accessories are listed
- Two trays offer less batch capacity than four- or five-tray sets
Best for: Individuals or small households who want a pair of basic, easy-release trays for regular drinks
Not ideal for: Buyers who need covered ice, a serving scoop, or enough trays for large gatherings
- Quantity:2 trays
- Capacity per tray:16 cubes
- Total capacity:32 cubes
- Material:Food-grade materials
- Made in:USA
- BPA-free:Yes
- Cleaning:Dishwasher safe
- Freezer storage:Stackable
Our verdict“Pick Kitch for simple, stackable trays and easy release, but choose a lidded set for odor protection or higher capacity.”
Weftnom Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lids, 5-Pack, 70 Cubes
For buyers who want a large batch of covered cubes, this Weftnom set makes 70 cubes across five trays, more than the 56-cube ChefAide 4-Pack. That added capacity can reduce how often you refill trays, while snap-on lids help limit spills and freezer odors. Flexible silicone bottoms make release easier, and the stated food-grade silicone and PP frame gives the trays a mix of flexible bases and firmer structure. This is also the most versatile choice here for freezing coffee, juice, herbs, sauces, or baby food. The catch is practical rather than technical: five trays need a dedicated patch of freezer space and add to washing and filling. Choose it for batch-making, not for a compact freezer.
Pros:- Makes 70 cubes across five trays
- Snap-on lids help limit spills and freezer odors
- Flexible bottoms help release cubes
- Dishwasher safe and described for use with other foods
Cons:- Five trays require substantial freezer space
- More trays mean more filling and washing than smaller sets
Best for: Meal planners and larger households that want covered cubes in several batches or freeze small portions of other foods
Not ideal for: People with limited freezer room or those who only need a small supply of ice
- Quantity:5 trays
- Cubes per tray:14
- Total capacity:70 cubes
- Materials:Food-grade silicone and PP frame
- BPA-free:Yes
- Cleaning:Dishwasher safe
- Freezer storage:Stackable with lids
- Model number:ICT-5P-14-MG
Our verdict“Choose Weftnom for a high-capacity, multi-use batch setup if you have freezer space for five trays.”
ChefAide 4-Pack Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lids
ChefAide is a practical middle ground between the two-tray Kitch set and the higher-capacity five-tray Weftnom pack. Four trays produce 56 rectangular cubes, and removable lids let them stack while helping shield ice from freezer odors. The flexible silicone bases release cubes without requiring a twist, which may suit buyers who find rigid trays awkward to bend. It also works beyond drinks, with the product described for baby food and other uses. The tradeoff is that the lids may come off more easily after a short wait, so quick access is not always the smoothest part of the routine. Four trays also take up more room than a compact two-tray set. I’d pick ChefAide for covered, moderate-capacity storage rather than minimal freezer footprint.
Pros:- Four trays make 56 cubes per batch
- Removable lids help protect against freezer odors
- Flexible bases release cubes without twisting
- Stackable and dishwasher safe
Cons:- Lids may be easier to remove after waiting about 30 seconds
- Four trays require more freezer space than a two-tray set
Best for: Households wanting several lidded trays that stack and can also freeze small portions of baby food
Not ideal for: Freezer-space-conscious buyers or anyone wanting lids that lift off immediately without waiting
- Number of trays:4
- Cubes per tray:14
- Total capacity:56 cubes
- Materials:Silicone and food-grade PP
- Lid:Removable
- Design:Stackable
- Cleaning:Dishwasher safe
Our verdict“Choose ChefAide for a covered, stackable set with useful batch capacity, provided you have room for four trays.”
DOQAUS Ice Cube Tray Set with Lids, Storage Bin, and Scoop, 4 Pack
This DOQAUS version makes the most sense for buyers who prioritize a complete storage routine and want BPA-free materials stated in the product details. It includes four silicone trays, a bin, and a scoop, much like the other DOQAUS set in this roundup; both also use stackable layouts and non-airtight lids. The difference is that this listing specifies food-grade silicone and durable plastic, giving buyers clearer material details than the first DOQAUS listing. Flexible bottoms help release cubes, while the bin gathers finished ice for serving. Still, the lids are not airtight, so I’d choose ChefAide instead if lid coverage against freezer odors is the priority. This set also asks for space for several trays plus its storage bin, making it less suited to a tightly packed freezer.
Pros:- Includes four trays, a storage bin, and a scoop
- Flexible bottoms help release cubes
- Stackable design helps save freezer space
- BPA-free and top-rack dishwasher safe
Cons:- Lids are not airtight
- The trays and bin need more storage room than a pair of trays
Best for: Buyers who want a BPA-free tray-and-bin kit for making, storing, and scooping ice
Not ideal for: People who need airtight protection from freezer odors or have limited room for a bin and four trays
- Included:4 silicone ice cube trays, storage bin, and scoop
- Materials:Food-grade silicone and durable plastic
- BPA-free:Yes
- Lids:Non-airtight; designed to minimize spills
- Freezer storage:Stackable
- Cleaning:Top-rack dishwasher safe
Our verdict“Choose this DOQAUS set for BPA-free materials and organized ice storage, but not for airtight coverage.”
5-Pack Stackable Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lids, Black
This five-tray set suits households that want several batches ready without relying on a separate storage bin. Each tray makes 14 cubes, for a stated 70-cube total; compared with the four-tray DOQAUS set, that means more trays available for drinks, meal prep, or frozen snacks. Flexible silicone is intended to make releasing cubes easier, while the lids help limit freezer odors and make stacking neater. The tradeoff is that these lids are not a shortcut to spill-free filling: the product instructions call for draining overflow before fitting them. I also can’t compare cube size or freezer fit with as much confidence because dimensions aren’t provided. Choose this set for volume and covered storage, not precise sizing details.
Pros:- Five trays make a stated total of 70 cubes
- Flexible silicone is designed to release cubes more easily
- Lids help protect ice from freezer odors
- Stackable design helps organize multiple trays
Cons:- Overflow needs to be drained before fitting the lids
- Tray and cube dimensions are not specified
Best for: Households that regularly need multiple batches of ice and want covered, stackable trays for drinks and frozen snacks
Not ideal for: Buyers who need a known cube size or tray dimensions to plan freezer space
- Quantity:5 trays
- Capacity per tray:14 cubes
- Total capacity:70 cubes
- Materials:Food-grade silicone and PP
- Color:Black
- Features:Stackable, reusable, with lids
Our verdict“Pick this set if you want 70 covered cubes across five trays and can work around the filling step and unspecified dimensions.”
DOQAUS Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lids, 4-Pack
The DOQAUS four-pack is a strong fit for buyers who want flexible trays but also care about cleanup and material details. Its dishwasher-safe construction makes it a more convenient care choice than the Rubbermaid Easy Release Ice Cube Trays, whose product details don’t specify dishwasher use. The silicone bottoms are designed to help cubes release, and the 10 × 4.1 × 3-inch dimensions give freezer planners more to work with than the dimension-free five-pack from B0DZML1NYR. LFGB certification and BPA-free materials are useful specifics for shoppers checking construction. The main compromise is its removable, spill-resistant lids: they are not airtight, so they can help with stacking and odors but don’t seal the trays completely. Cube capacity and size aren’t specified.
Pros:- Flexible silicone bottoms are designed to ease cube release
- Dishwasher-safe trays simplify cleanup
- LFGB certified and BPA-free
- Tray dimensions are provided for freezer planning
Cons:- Removable lids are not airtight
- Cube capacity and individual cube dimensions are not specified
Best for: Freezer organizers who want stackable silicone trays, dishwasher cleanup, and documented material details
Not ideal for: Buyers who need an airtight lid or want a stated cube count and cube dimensions
- Quantity:4 trays
- Dimensions:10 × 4.1 × 3 in
- Materials:Silicone and polypropylene
- Certifications and materials:LFGB certified, BPA-free, odor-free
- Lid type:Removable, spill-resistant; not airtight
- Design:Stackable with flexible silicone bottoms
- Care:Dishwasher safe
Our verdict“Choose DOQAUS for dishwasher-friendly flexible trays with stated dimensions, but skip it if airtight storage is a requirement.”
Rubbermaid Easy Release Ice Cube Trays, 2-Pack, Light Purple
Rubbermaid’s two-pack keeps the pitch simple: a pair of break-resistant, stackable trays designed for easy release, without lids or specialty materials taking center stage. Compared with the four-tray Kitch Easy Release set, this is a smaller-format choice for buyers who need a basic supply of ice rather than several batches at once. The stated break-resistant construction may appeal to households that prefer a sturdy everyday tray, and easy cleaning keeps the routine straightforward. The tradeoff is limited product detail: neither material nor cube capacity is provided, so I can’t tell buyers what the trays are made from or how much ice they make. There’s also no lid feature specified for odor protection or covered stacking. It’s a practical, restrained pick, but not the most informative one.
Pros:- Designed for easy cube release
- Stacks in the freezer without sticking
- Break-resistant construction is described
- Easy-to-clean design
Cons:- Material and cube capacity are not specified
- No lid feature is listed for covered storage or odor protection
Best for: Buyers who want two straightforward, stackable trays with an emphasis on durability and easy release
Not ideal for: Shoppers who need a known material, defined cube capacity, or covered trays for freezer odor protection
- Pack size:2 trays
- Color:Light purple
- Release design:Designed for easy release
- Freezer storage:Stackable without sticking
- Durability:Break-resistant
- Cleaning:Described as easy to clean
Our verdict“Choose this Rubbermaid pair for a simple, durable tray format, but look elsewhere if material and capacity details matter to your purchase.”
Kitch Easy Release White Ice Cube Trays, 4-Pack
Kitch combines a clear cube count with a straightforward flexible-tray design: four trays make 64 cubes total, with 16 in each. That gives buyers a more predictable supply than the Rubbermaid two-pack, whose capacity isn’t specified, while keeping the format simpler than the lidded silicone sets. The twist-to-release design is intended to free cubes without individually prying them out, and the trays stack and are dishwasher safe. Food-grade materials, BPA-free construction, and U.S. manufacture are useful details for shoppers comparing basic trays. The tradeoff is that no lids are listed, so these don’t offer the covered storage of the DOQAUS four-pack. Cube dimensions also aren’t provided, which limits comparisons for drink glass fit or portion sizing.
Pros:- Four trays make 64 cubes, with 16 per tray
- Flexible design supports twist release
- Stackable and dishwasher safe
- BPA-free food-grade materials; made in the USA
Cons:- No lids are listed for covered storage
- Cube dimensions are not specified
Best for: Buyers who want a stated four-tray capacity, dishwasher-safe cleanup, and trays made in the USA
Not ideal for: Shoppers who want lidded trays to help protect ice from freezer odors or need defined cube dimensions
- Pack size:4 trays
- Cubes per tray:16
- Total capacity:64 cubes
- Color:White
- Material:Food-grade materials
- BPA-free:Yes
- Care and storage:Dishwasher safe and stackable
- Made in:USA
Our verdict“Pick Kitch for a defined 64-cube supply and simple dishwasher-safe care, but choose a lidded set if freezer protection is a priority.”
8-Pack Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Removable Lids, 14 Cubes per Tray
This set stands out for giving buyers an approximate cube size—about 1.8 × 1.3 × 0.9 inches—which the five-pack from B0DZML1NYR does not provide. That detail can help shoppers judge whether the cubes suit their glasses or frozen portions. The eight-tray format and removable lids also support stacking and help keep freezer odors away from the ice; soft TPE bottoms are designed to make release easier. There is, however, a capacity inconsistency in the supplied details: eight trays at 14 cubes each would be 112 cubes, while the stated total is 56. I’d verify the count before choosing it for bulk supply. Its silicone, TPE, and PP construction also combines several materials rather than a single-material tray.
Pros:- Approximate cube dimensions and liquid capacity are provided
- Soft TPE bottoms are designed to ease cube release
- Removable lids help with stacking and freezer odors
- BPA-free materials
Cons:- Capacity figures conflict: eight trays with 14 cubes each imply 112 cubes, not the stated 56
- Construction combines silicone, TPE, and PP
Best for: Buyers who want approximate cube dimensions and multiple lidded trays for stacking or frozen portions
Not ideal for: Shoppers relying on an exact total cube count or seeking a tray made from one material
- Pack size:8 trays
- Cubes per tray:14
- Stated total capacity:56 cubes; inconsistent with 8 trays × 14 cubes
- Materials:Silicone, TPE, and PP
- BPA-free:Yes
- Cube dimensions:About 1.8 × 1.3 × 0.9 in
- Liquid capacity per cube:About 0.88 oz
- Colors:4 blue and 4 green
- Lids:Removable
Our verdict“Choose this set if cube dimensions matter more than a confirmed total capacity, and verify the tray count before relying on it for bulk ice.”
How We Picked
I compared the 15 listings by the details that change day-to-day use: stated tray count and cube capacity, material, release-oriented design, lids, stackability, and included storage accessories. I gave more weight to a useful balance of release and storage than to sheer piece count alone, since extra trays are less helpful if a freezer setup is awkward or the buyer does not need a large batch.
The ranking distinguishes simple trays from silicone sets and accessory bundles instead of treating them as interchangeable. Product names and listed features guide these comparisons; I do not claim hands-on testing or infer unlisted performance. The two DOQAUS entries describe the same set, so their repeated appearance does not count as evidence of two distinct designs.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Ice Cube Trays
Before choosing a set, match its design to how you freeze and use ice. The tradeoffs go beyond material: batch size, storage space, and how you handle a full tray can matter just as much.
Choose a Batch Size You Can Store
Start with how much ice you use between freezer refills, not the largest cube count you can find. A high-capacity set, such as a multi-tray option listing 70 cubes, suits frequent entertaining or households that go through ice quickly. For occasional drinks, a smaller set may leave more freezer room for food. Remember that cube count is not the same as usable storage: trays need room to sit flat while filling and freezing. Buying more trays than your freezer can hold level can make a generous set frustrating to use.
Think About Release and Handling Together
Flexible silicone is designed to bend around frozen cubes, while firmer plastic trays hold their shape during filling and moving. Neither material automatically makes a tray easier for every buyer: flexibility can help with release, but a full silicone tray may need more support on its way to the freezer. A rigid tray can be simpler to carry flat, yet some buyers may prefer a design meant to make removal easier. Consider where you will fill the tray and how far you must carry it. If spills are a concern, prioritize a setup you can move steadily rather than choosing by material label alone.
Decide Whether Lids Solve a Real Problem
A lid can help contain splashes during transport and separate the tray from other freezer contents. It also adds another piece to wash and store, and it does not automatically mean a filled tray can be carried at any angle. Check whether the lid is described as removable and whether the tray design supports stacking before assuming it will save space. If trays sit undisturbed in a dedicated freezer spot, an uncovered tray may be sufficient. Choose a lid for a specific storage or handling need, not just because it appears in a product name.
Compare Complete Sets With Basic Trays
Storage bins and scoops can make a set more convenient if you like to empty cubes into a shared container and keep the trays ready for another batch. Those add-ons take up space, though, and may be unnecessary if you use ice directly from the tray. A basic two-tray set keeps the setup simpler, while a multi-piece bundle can cover more steps at once. Before selecting a bundle, check whether its included parts fit your freezer and routine. Extra accessories add value only when you will actually use them.
Match the Set to Your Freezer Layout
Measure the shelf or drawer where you plan to freeze the trays, including room to slide them in without tilting. A tall stack may save width but can be inconvenient if you cannot lift the upper tray without disturbing the lower one. Flat, stable placement matters while water freezes, so avoid assuming every lidded tray can be stacked immediately. If freezer space is tight, a compact two-pack may be easier to manage than a larger bundle. For a crowded freezer, prioritize the tray footprint and storage method over the number of included pieces.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are silicone or plastic ice cube trays a better choice?
Neither material is best for every kitchen. Silicone trays are flexible, which can help when releasing cubes, but a filled tray may need more support during transport. Plastic trays tend to keep a firmer shape, which some buyers may find easier to carry level. Compare the material alongside lids, tray count, and the way you plan to remove and store cubes. The OXO flexible tray and the plastic Arrow and Kitch options represent different handling priorities in this roundup.
Do I need an ice cube tray with a lid?
A lid is useful if you want to cover water while moving a tray or keep it separated from other freezer contents. It can also make stacking more practical when the product is designed for that use. A lid adds a part to clean and can take up storage space when removed. If your freezer has a stable, dedicated spot and you do not move trays while full, a basic tray may be enough. Choose a covered set for the specific storage or handling problem it solves.
How many ice cube trays should I buy?
Base the number on how quickly your household uses ice and how much freezer room you can spare for flat trays. A two-tray set may suit occasional use, while the Weftnom 5-Pack listing 70 cubes is aimed at buyers who want a larger batch. More trays can reduce how often you refill, but only if you have room to freeze them and store the finished cubes. A bin can help separate ready ice from trays still in use. Check your freezer dimensions before buying a multi-pack.
Is a tray set with a storage bin and scoop worth choosing?
It can be a good fit if you regularly empty trays into a shared supply and want a scoop for serving. The DOQAUS set combines trays with a bin and scoop, unlike basic sets that focus on making cubes. Those extras may be redundant if you use cubes straight from the tray or already have a freezer container. Also account for the room the bin occupies. Compare the full setup with a simpler tray set based on your routine, not the number of included pieces alone.
Why are there two DOQAUS sets with a storage bin and scoop in this roundup?
The two listings both name a DOQAUS 4-piece set with lids, a storage bin, and a scoop. The supplied details do not establish a design difference between them, so I treat them as duplicate listings rather than separate options with distinct advantages. Buyers should compare the listing details carefully before choosing either one. If the products appear identical, there is little reason to rank them as different tray designs. The DOQAUS silicone tray set without the bin and scoop is a separate listed option.
Conclusion
For most buyers, I recommend the OXO Good Grips Flexible Ice Cube Tray with Lid as the best overall choice: it combines a flexible tray design and a lid without making the purchase a larger accessory bundle. For best value by tray count, the Kitch Easy Release White Ice Cube Trays 4-Pack offers more trays than the two-pack listings, though the product name alone does not establish a price advantage. For a best premium-style, accessory-rich setup, choose the DOQAUS set with a storage bin and scoop if you will use those extras. Beginners who want a straightforward covered option can start with OXO; buyers who prefer a simpler plastic tray can compare Arrow or Kitch. For large batches, the Weftnom 5-Pack lists 70 cubes, while buyers seeking many individually lidded trays can look at the 8-Pack listing. Choose by freezer fit and routine first, then narrow the options by material and included accessories.
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
